CasualContracts
communicationexpectationsmaintenance

The Check-In Conversation: A Guide to Regular Arrangement Reviews

·6 min read

A casual arrangement without regular check-ins is like a car without oil changes — it might run fine for a while, but eventually something seizes up. Check-in conversations are the maintenance that keeps your arrangement running smoothly, catches small problems before they become big ones, and gives both people permission to speak honestly about how things are going.

Most arrangements that fail don't fail because of one big catastrophe. They fail because small misalignments went unaddressed for too long. A regular check-in prevents that.

What a Check-In Is (and Isn't)

A check-in IS:

  • A scheduled, low-pressure conversation about how the arrangement is working
  • An opportunity for both people to share what's going well and what could improve
  • A chance to update or revise terms as circumstances change
  • A commitment to the health of the arrangement

A check-in IS NOT:

  • A performance review where one person evaluates the other
  • A therapy session for processing deep emotional issues
  • An opportunity to deliver a list of grievances
  • A precursor to ending things (unless that's genuinely what needs to happen)

How Often to Check In

The right frequency depends on how new the arrangement is and how often you see each other:

  • First three months: Check in every 2-4 weeks. Things are still being figured out, patterns are forming, and adjustments are frequent.
  • Three to six months: Monthly check-ins work well for most arrangements.
  • Six months and beyond: Every 6-8 weeks, unless something comes up that requires an earlier conversation.
  • After any significant event: A change in someone's life circumstances, a disagreement, a boundary issue, or a shift in feelings all warrant an unscheduled check-in.

The Check-In Structure

Here's a framework that keeps the conversation productive without making it feel like a corporate meeting:

Part 1: What's Working (5-10 minutes)

Start positive. Each person shares one or two things about the arrangement that they appreciate, enjoy, or want to continue. This sets the tone and reminds both people why the arrangement exists.

Examples:

  • "I really appreciate how consistent you've been with scheduling. It makes me feel respected."
  • "I love that we can be honest with each other. That's rare and I value it."
  • "The financial side has been smooth and predictable, which helps me a lot."

Part 2: What Could Improve (10-15 minutes)

This is where adjustments happen. Each person shares one or two areas where they'd like something to change. Frame these constructively — not "you're doing this wrong" but "I'd like us to try this differently."

Examples:

  • "I'd like us to communicate a bit more between meetups. Even a couple texts during the week would be nice." (See how often to communicate.)
  • "The last couple of times, we've run over on time and it's made my evenings complicated. Can we be more intentional about wrapping up?"
  • "I'd like to revisit the financial terms. My situation has changed and I think we should discuss an adjustment."

Ground rules for this section:

  • One issue at a time. Don't dump everything at once.
  • The other person listens fully before responding.
  • No defensiveness. This is information, not an attack.
  • If an issue needs more discussion than the check-in allows, schedule a separate conversation for it.

Part 3: Logistics and Updates (5-10 minutes)

Cover any practical changes:

  • Upcoming schedule changes (travel, busy periods, holidays)
  • Financial adjustments
  • Changes to communication preferences
  • Updates to boundaries or rules
  • Any life changes that affect the arrangement (new job, moving, relationship status changes)

Part 4: Confirm and Close (2-5 minutes)

Summarize any changes agreed upon during the check-in. Be specific:

  • "So we're going to try texting more during the week — maybe every other day."
  • "We'll revisit the allowance amount at our next check-in after you've had time to think about it."
  • "Our next check-in will be [date]."

End on a positive note. Reaffirm the arrangement if it's working: "I'm glad we're doing this. I feel good about where we are."

Check-In Questions Worth Asking

Keep these in your back pocket for when the conversation needs a prompt:

About satisfaction:

  • "On a scale of 1-10, how happy are you with how things are going? What would make it a point higher?"
  • "Is there anything you wish we did more of? Less of?"

About boundaries:

  • "Have any of your boundaries shifted since we last talked?"
  • "Is there anything I've done that felt uncomfortable, even if it seemed small?"

About the future:

  • "Do you see this arrangement continuing as-is for the next few months?"
  • "Is there anything on the horizon that might change things for you?"

About feelings:

  • "How are you feeling about us emotionally? Same as before, or has anything shifted?"
  • "Is the casual nature of this still working for you, or are you wanting something different?"

That last question takes courage to ask. But it's better to know the answer now than to find out months later that one person has been wanting more all along.

What People Get Wrong About Check-Ins

Waiting until something is wrong. The whole point of regular check-ins is to catch issues early. If you only talk when there's a problem, every "can we talk?" becomes a source of anxiety.

Making it one-sided. Both people should be sharing, listening, and adjusting. If one person does all the talking and the other just nods, the check-in isn't working.

Being dishonest to keep the peace. If something is bothering you and you say "everything's great" to avoid conflict, you've wasted the check-in. Honesty is the whole point, even when it's uncomfortable.

Skipping them when things are going well. Especially then. Check-ins during good times reinforce positive patterns and give you a track record of healthy communication to draw on when things get rocky.

Turning it into a negotiation. The check-in is a conversation, not a contract renegotiation. If major terms need to change, note it during the check-in and schedule a dedicated conversation.

Making Check-Ins Feel Natural

If "scheduling a relationship review" sounds unbearably clinical, here are ways to make it feel more organic:

  • Tie it to a regular activity. "Let's grab dinner on the first Friday of each month and use that as our check-in."
  • Keep it conversational. You don't need a clipboard and an agenda. Two people talking honestly over coffee is a check-in.
  • Use a simple opener. "Hey, it's been a month since we last really talked about how this is going. How are you feeling about everything?"
  • Don't overthink it. The goal isn't perfection. It's connection and honesty.

When a Check-In Reveals a Bigger Problem

Sometimes a routine check-in uncovers something significant — one person has developed feelings, someone's circumstances have changed dramatically, or there's a fundamental incompatibility that wasn't visible before.

If that happens, don't try to resolve it in the check-in. Acknowledge it, schedule time to discuss it properly, and approach it with the same honesty that made you bring it up in the first place.

For guidance on navigating these moments, see When One Person Wants Out or Handling Disagreements.

The Bottom Line

Regular check-ins are the single most effective tool for maintaining a healthy casual arrangement. They prevent misunderstandings, create space for honesty, and prove that both people are invested in making the arrangement work for everyone.

Schedule your first one. You'll be glad you did.

For more communication tools, visit our Communication and Boundaries hub.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified attorney for advice specific to your situation.